Joe Montana vs Tom Brady

[Aremaz95]

For you who is the true best quarterback? Or do you like another one like Dan Marino?

 

[jho]

Brady will probably be the best of all time whenever he hangs it all up

 

[lilpotato]

Brady.

 

[imhighhommie]

Brady is the GOAT, no doubt. I mean he's probably about to get another ring this year too lol

 

[Max Diver]

Brady is incredible. So many years so many titles on such a high level...

He is the best of all time. And might win another SB this year ! Patriots flying...

 

[steeler1970]

It is not Brady he is a cheater so i would Joe is the best ever

 

[AlbieTross]

Easy answer; Brady

 

[don1980]

I dislike the patriots. So I would say Joe or even Peyton Manning, John Elway and Dan Marino.

 

[lcid86]

Have to give it to Brady due to longevity and titles. He's won with receivers most other teams wouldn't take.

 

[Blackout09]

Brady will retire as The Greatest QB Ever If he wins This Super Bowl.

 

[jignesh_cse]

Tom Brady............

 

[terryk]

I grew up watching Joe Montana win Super Bowls(what did he weigh? 175? lol) But Tom Brady has done more with less,,,,Brady wins.:icon_chee

 

[ribbybruno]

Brady will retire as The Greatest QB Ever If he wins This Super Bowl.

Definitely! Gonna be hard to argue with Tom if he does.

 

[99TERRANCE99]

Super joe was awesome but had more of an established set and r receivers and hall of famers around him brady does it with many different levels of players he is more clutch i take brady hands down if i get a choice which qb to start my team with .

 

[NHequalsFU]

1. Brady2. Everyone else.


JK, but seriously anyone who argues against TB12 has no argument. Here is my top 5.


1. Brady
2. Montana
3. Manning
4. Marino
5. Elway


I think had Marino had some help and won a few titles he would be in contention for GOAT. Brady probably benefitted from Belichik's system and Montana had the better weapons plus good system. Manning had weapons but no D in Indy. Elway sneaks in my top5 over Favre since Favre threw so many INTs.

 

[grilldoggy]

Sure, the proof is in the pudding. Brady has more Super Bowls. Montana would have done the same if he played on these Patriot teams, so would a lot of qb's. The Patriots manipulate the system to their advantage, that's the edge.

 

[Stacker]

I would take either. They both had a great system. Montana had more talent around him

 

[trippin]

No single quarterback will do what Brady has done, he is easily the greatest QB of all time, for get passing yards, TD's, rings. He will destroy every defense thrown at him. He makes bench WR's look like superstars.

 

[PapesOnlyy]

Tom Brady is better by far.... way more accomplishments in Football

 

[99TERRANCE99]

Brady by alot

 

[ssi8]

I think all the same Brady, he's the best, I think so

 

[Four Dogs]

Tom Brady is the GOAT. He's not a cheater. His wife is hot. And he's not done yet.

 

[Jammen]

I'm a Buffalo Bills fan and I hate Tom Brady as a football player more than any other player in the history of the sport. That being said he is hands down the greatest of all time. Its not even close!! And I hate him for that too.

 

[Jammen]

come on! He is a cheater and he is the GOAT also. Just because he's one doesn't mean he's not the other.

 

[vse i sra3y]

I've never seen the game of Dan Marino, so for me Tom Brady)