Jblocher1 said:
I was arguing with my family about this topic. Given that the definition of professional is that you are paid some sort of salary. Given that poker has an element of luck to it and you are gambling, can you actually be a professional.
It is in my belief that you can be but I need some educated forumers to back me up here. My family argues that since you are not payed a set salary for being skilled in it you can't be a professional. They say no matter how good you are, or how much u make, you will always be an amateur
Thoughts?
Dang, I love that kind of back and forth in a family conversation.....it is the sign of a family that conversates about topics and brainstorms...awesome
consider Trading financial markets for a living. As a trader, you are trying to make money consistently over a month or longer. While the results pooled from all your days trading will amount to a net positive or net negative month, as a trader you are concerned more about how much you made over the month or even year than about how much you made over a week.
Now you can choose to work for a company and get a steady salary or you can decide to work for your own account. But if you are any good, you will not want the salary: you will want to trade for your own account to garner the greater reward. The trouble is, that you will not have 12 consecutively positive months throughout the year. And so you could clear $25,000 one month, lose $5,000 another month, and on average make around $15,000 for 10 months straight yet there will be a month or two when you had a net negative result. Now by the end of the year you will have made around $170,000 minus the taxes you pay on that (let's say 33% to be fair as certain financial instruments are taxed differently than others...in particular stocks versus futures). So at the end of the year you will have cleared around $114,000....yet there may have been a month or two when you did not get a paycheck. Would your family consider that the work of a professional?
Trading and poker are very much different beasts of the same animal (that animal being RISK itself) and so I think the analogy is fitting here.
So you don't need a consistent paycheck to be a professional; in endeavors of risk, such as trading and poker, what matters most is your bottom line at the end of the year or, even better, your bottom line at the end of three years or longer!