What Actually Makes You Stick With a Casino?

There are so many online casinos competing for players these days, and I’m curious about what actually makes people choose one casino over another — and, more importantly, what makes you keep coming back.

For me, things like good game selection and promotions are important when trying a new casino, but they aren’t necessarily what makes me stay. Reliable withdrawals, quick support, a decent loyalty/VIP program, and simply having a good experience over time probably matter much more.

So I’d be interested to hear what everyone else thinks:

What are the top 3 things that make you stay loyal to an online casino?

Would you prioritize:
Fast and reliable withdrawals?
Better bonuses and promotions?
Game selection and software providers?
VIP rewards and loyalty benefits?
Customer support?
Trust/reputation and a good track record?
Something else entirely?

And has there ever been a casino you stopped using because of one particular issue, even though you initially liked it?

Interested to hear some different perspectives — especially whether people value bonuses/promotions more when joining, but trust, withdrawals and service more once they've been playing there for a while.

For me: fast withdrawals, trust, and good support. Bonuses are nice when joining, but once I’m playing, I care more about a casino being reliable and hassle-free.

It's clear that you're talking about online casinos only. Ones I'm not really fond of.
Sorry if I'm replying though, but I have an answer, except that it's in regard to live casinos.

I stick with a casino mainly because of the quality and the value of their comps.

Rooms.
Show tickets.
Food.
Free quality merch in stores within the premises (Paid for by accumulated points).
.
.
.

That's not my case! But it's probably the betting addiction...

Good poker action
Good promos
Restaurants that I like
Convenient location

Trust and reputation is number one before considering other factors.

Promotions that are fair to a casual player so you can chip up with their help.

Never had a problem with withdrawals, but that is key.

I've experienced bad/rogue customer support but it would have to be consistently bad to be a big factor.

Fast payouts, hands down. Nothing kills the vibe faster than having to wait three days and send 10 different documents just to cash out a hundred bucks. If a site pays out instantly (or at least same-day) and doesn't give me a hard time with KYC, I'm sticking around. Bonus points if their mobile UI isn't a laggy mess.