David macdonald
Legend
Bronze Level
- Joined
- Jan 22, 2017
- Total posts
- 3,474
- Awards
- 18
- Poker Chips
- 296
- Casino Coins
- 0
- #26
Agreed
OzExorcist said:It's never bothered me.
The way the actual hand played out is fine - as opposed to the straight flush-boat-boat-flush contrived nonsense of the final hand in Casino Royale (which isn't even the worst hand in that movie).
I agree it seems incredibly unlikely a normal person would be mucking the best hand in the same spot as Eric Bana's character, but if that's a "problem" it's with the character, not the actual poker. Plus no normal person has ever found themself in the final three of the WSOP Main Event playing against their dad and some douchebag.
caio cesar said:The whole scenario was unrealistic. He flat calls with aces, why? You usually do that to trap your opponents. why didn't he start a pre flop 5 bet war to build a pot and then fold, why go to the river and muck? And how Robert Duvall's character knows he mucked a winning hand and knows it was aces? Like it happens all the time a AA x KK clash 3-handed.. Ok, let's say he knows his son gave up of the hand. How he knows it was aces? Why not a better hand like a set or two pair?
OzExorcist said:This whole discussion should probably have had a spoiler alert on it BTW, but anywho...
*shrugs*
I think you're missing the point - the way he played the hand was so that it didn't look like he had AA. In fact I suspect getting into a five-bet pot preflop against your Dad and then just folding would be a pretty good way to get yourself caught (or to get your opponent to fold their hand - which is the opposite of what he wants).
It's been ages since I've watched the movie, but IIRC the way he went about it did a pretty good job of making it seem like he had some other legit hand that could still lose (his backer thought he had QQ, right?). Which, one assumes, is what you'd WANT to do when you're breaking the tournament rules to dump chips to your Dad.
As for Duvall "knowing" his son had AA? Call that dramatic license.
caio cesar said:No, I'm not "missing the point".The hand from start to collusion does not make a sense at all.
And you trying to defend it it's borderline ridiculous. You said that his backer thought he had QQ. How on earth do you call pre flop with QQ three handed? To put him on QQ is beyond stupid.
victoor_06 said:I don't recommend it, "Missisippi Grind" the worst movie about poker and casino :hmpf:
Rational Madman said:Dan negreanus autobio mini film "kid poker" I enjoyed