Was I correct in doing this?

Emily Trott

Emily Trott

Legend
Loyaler
Awards
7
US
Poker Chips
1,280
Casino Coins
60
The blinds moved from 800-1600 to 1000-2000 as the hand was being completed. I'm in seat 8 and the big blind (BB) in #6 only puts in 1600 (small blind only put 800). I didn't notice until the cards were being dealt and didn't mention that the blinds were wrong.

On the next hand I was under the gun and once again the blinds put in the incorrect amounts. I kept my mouth shut again, intending to put in the correct BB on the next deal when it was my turn. The BB noticed it and told the dealer, so we played the correct BB on that hand. Was I wrong to remain silent?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Chica_bonita
Emily Trott said:
The blinds moved from 800-1600 to 1000-2000 as the hand was being completed. I'm in seat 8 and the big blind (BB) in #6 only puts in 1600 (small blind only put 800). I didn't notice until the cards were being dealt and didn't mention that the blinds were wrong.

On the next hand I was under the gun and once again the blinds put in the incorrect amounts. I kept my mouth shut again, intending to put in the correct BB on the next deal when it was my turn. The BB noticed it and told the dealer, so we played the correct BB on that hand. Was I wrong to remain silent?
Yes and no, The dealer is responsible for what is going on, if the dealer can't keep up with the table, that is who is wrong.
If by keeping your mouth shut there was an edge obtained then you came out to the good.
I have played in lots of tournaments that dealers give a break on the first hand changing blinds.
On the first hand that seems to happen a lot and is more or less understood.
The second hand should have been the 1k-2k blinds. The dealer was asleep at the wheel.
Someone should have said something on the second hand before there was any action.

Where I play there is a written set of tournament rules and it states:
Dealer Errors--In case of a dealer error, the floor manager will make the final decision, which may involve correcting the mistake or allowing players to adjust their actions based on the situation.

Where I play they use Poker Tournament Directors Association rules.
Run them off and study them and know the rules.
Snake the dealer at Pop's told me to get the rules and study them as if you study and know the rules this gives you an edge over the 95% of people who have not a clue as to the rules.
 
Generally under tournament rules you should speak up if you see a mistake, although the dealer and tournament staff are ultimately responsible for administering the correct blinds.

You can do it in a passive way before the action starts, "Are the blinds correct? Didn't they just go up?" rather than "Hey you two, post the right blinds" 😝

See player responsibilities:

TDA rule No. 2, called Player Responsibilities, was added at the most recent TDA Summit and is worded as follows: “Players are expected to verify registration data and seat assignments, protect their hands, make their intentions clear, follow the action, act in turn, defend their right to act, keep cards visible, keep chips correctly stacked, remain at the table with a live hand, speak up if they see a mistake being made, transfer tables promptly, follow one player to a hand, know and comply with the rules, follow proper etiquette, and generally contribute to an orderly tournament.”

It's not optional.
 
Gutshot Gus said:
Yes and no, The dealer is responsible for what is going on, if the dealer can't keep up with the table, that is who is wrong.
If by keeping your mouth shut there was an edge obtained then you came out to the good.
I have played in lots of tournaments that dealers give a break on the first hand changing blinds.
On the first hand that seems to happen a lot and is more or less understood.
The second hand should have been the 1k-2k blinds. The dealer was asleep at the wheel.
Someone should have said something on the second hand before there was any action.

Where I play there is a written set of tournament rules and it states:
Dealer Errors--In case of a dealer error, the floor manager will make the final decision, which may involve correcting the mistake or allowing players to adjust their actions based on the situation.

Where I play they use Poker Tournament Directors Association rules.
Run them off and study them and know the rules.
Snake the dealer at Pop's told me to get the rules and study them as if you study and know the rules this gives you an edge over the 95% of people who have not a clue as to the rules.
"Yes and no, "

It's an unequivocal NO under the rules you quoted, if you see a mistake you have to speak up.

The problem is by not speaking up:
You can gain an edge on the players at other tables who are now playing higher blinds;
You can pass an edge to either the blinds or other players behind you by allowing them to play at lower blinds (imagine they are your buddies).
 
Emily Trott said:
The blinds moved from 800-1600 to 1000-2000 as the hand was being completed. I'm in seat 8 and the big blind (BB) in #6 only puts in 1600 (small blind only put 800). I didn't notice until the cards were being dealt and didn't mention that the blinds were wrong.

On the next hand I was under the gun and once again the blinds put in the incorrect amounts. I kept my mouth shut again, intending to put in the correct BB on the next deal when it was my turn. The BB noticed it and told the dealer, so we played the correct BB on that hand. Was I wrong to remain silent?
It is an error to not tell the dealer- had you a playable hand UTG and raised and then someone else told the dealer that is a misdeal- further if you did raise and win the blinds you won less than you would have if the blinds were correct only to put the correct amount in the very next hand.

🤔🤓
 
This is one of those tricky ones that, as we have seen in the thread, you should do, but also is totally unenforcable, as no one but you knows if you know they went up or not.

You don't really want be the one to point out that the BB has to put in an extra 800 chips, assuming BB ante. But like @monkeytilter says its best to just find a way to do it, like 'oh dealer, blinds are up' make it like you are helping him/her out rather than making the BB pay more, or whatever makes you feel more comfortable!
 
I can't see you really doing anything wrong. It's the dealer's responsibility, not yours. I get it, you have a 'duty' to report an error that you notice, but 7 other players also did not point out the error. Are they in violation too, or just you since you are the only one astute enough to notice? Kind of stupid to penalize you and only you for simply being sharper than the other 7.
 
The dealer owns the mistake, but under standard TDA style rules players are expected to speak up when they see one, and a new level applies from the next hand dealt. So the first hand is a grey area, but by the second hand someone should have called it before any action. Saying nothing is not cheating, it is just not what the rules ask of you.
 
Back
Top