Gipsystripsy said:
I love people like you who keep telling others they're lying. There is plenty of proof that I DO play winning poker simply because I learned the basics, which you might have never even heard of.
He's not telling you that you are lying. He's just telling you that you are wrong. There is a difference. Lying is an attempt to deceive. You are not attempting to deceive anyone. You genuinely trying to help, but you are mistaken. So it is important that you be corrected so that your advice leads no one astray.
As for poker basics making you a winning player, your pre-flop ranges and your c-bet frequencies, etc at the table has nothing to do with your bankroll and this thread is about bankroll. Furthermore, the term 'winning player' is relative to the stakes that one plays and you admittedly play freerolls and some penny stakes. Perhaps you are a winning player at freerolls but that does not take skill, simply perseverance. Are you a winning player at penny stakes? It looks like not since your bankroll is exclusively built through freerolls.
If you had built up say 50 dollars from freerolls and used that as a a starter, to move on to 2NL and began building that through 2NL grinds, then you could argue that you are a winning player, but you haven't done anything to demonstrate that.
Gipsystripsy said:
And honestly, I'm glad there are still players like you who think success is measured only by the number of zeros in their bankroll.
In the context of 'winning player', actually yes, success is 100% measured in winnings.
Gipsystripsy said:
Before you can walk, you first have to crawl. A LOSING player dreams about sprinting while making fun of someone who's still crawling. Nobody is given success for free. You have to earn it through hard work.
If you want to make money with poker, you MUST master these basics first. Otherwise, you'll never reach the level you're talking about. That's exactly why my advice about freerolls could be very valuable for new players.
Fundiver is probably the smartest contributor to this forum and reading his posts, it is clear that he has much experience playing micro stakes poker. You can't tell someone how to make money at poker if you have not made it yourself. You have 120 dollars from freerolls and you have not managed to grow that bankroll in
real money stakes, so you have not made any money at poker. Not trying to be rude, but a cat walking on your keyboard can make 120 dollars at freerolls if it plays long enough. Why should anyone take your advice on making money at poker, let alone fundiver?
Playing freerolls long enough can teach you how to beat freerollers (people who don't give a damn about their stack or their bankroll), but even with that experience and knowledge, the variance in freerolls is so high that your skill edge will only be a small advantage. However, once you move to 2NL, a lot of those players do care about their stacks and bankrolls and your freeroll skill edge won't help you much there neither.
You talk about hard work. You need to grind. Playing 2 or 3 freerolls per week is not work. You need to play every day and if you don't have the time to play 5 or 6 times per week, then those 3 or 4 hours that you have once or twice per week you need to have 2 or 3 or 4 tables open and grind. You need to be playing 2cent cash and 50cent or 1dollar tournaments, and play and play and play to keep that volume up, grind and work.
Gipsystripsy said:
All my stats below were earned through freerolls. And GG offers daily freebies, which are fantastic for starting a bankroll.
Agree, for STARTING a bankroll, but not building one. Once you have 50 or 100 bucks, you need to move on to real money or you're not trying.
Gipsystripsy said:
I PLAY POKER AS A HOBBY! It's a CHALLENGE for me. I only play a few times a week, so don't come with the usual "long-term blah blah."
But it IS long term if you want to be a winning player. The better players ONLY beat the variance with volume. That is literally how it is done. You admit that you only play as a hobby, casually a couple of times per week. That is wonderful. Poker is a great hobby, especially if you only play freerolls, that is a lot of hobby fun. But you are not qualified to advise newer players and that is why fundiver counters your advice - not to put you in your place (as you have arrogantly tried to do to him), but to correct the misguided information that you put forth.
A bankroll is simply the ratio of money kept behind to survive the variance of the stakes that one plays, and going by your advice in this thread, you do not understand that, therefore, you should not be advising new players on bankroll.
Sorry if this hurts your feelings, but it has to be said.