MrPokerVerse said:
You start off with an equal math equation that is unproven and also cancels itself out. So really, why no state that if you take luck out of the picture, skill is the main factor and everyone is lucky and it evens out.
So luck doesn’t contribute to any long term variable and the most skilled players have an advantage. Essentially luck contributes zero percent to the over all statically players success and skill is the deciding factor?
That was deep dude. So you really want a formula? Let's decide how many "luck elements" there are in a hand and how many "skill elements" there are in a hand.
When I get dealt AA preflop, I have to consider that this was good luck, then when my opponent flops a set I have to consider that this was bad luck until I spike an A on the river and now have set over set so in the end I have good luck. Every card dealt is good luck or bad luck so there are 9 elements of luck in a heads up hand (my 2, your 2 and the 5 on the board = 9 "luck elements" in a hand).
Every decision made (skill element) requires skill. So how many "skill elements" are there in a hand? If we fold preflop, there is only one decision made based on two cards seen: skill to luck ratio is 1:2 (33% skill). If we get to showdown, there will be a minimum of 4 decisions made: skill to luck ratio is 4:9 (31% skill). If there are re-raises, check-raises, or 3bets made a long the way, we will have additional decisions to make. A quick look at some hand history data, and the hands where I have made more than 4 decisions per hand is less than 2% of the time. But of course these are probably high impact hands. I have never made more than 6 decisions in a single hand. Of course games with high levels of aggression will require more, but on average, I would say the average is no more than 5 decisions per hand. Average skill to luck ratio in showdown hands then might be 5:9 (36%).
So in summary, skill actually accounts for between 31% and 36% of the game. Of course not all skill is good, some of it is poor skill and just guessing.
If it weren't for bad luck I would have no luck at all!
If it weren't for poor skill I would have no skill at all!
Good luck and God bless.