I am amused by online poker defenders who have not even touched a professional poker play
Last edited:
I think differently, many times it is only people in good faith who are being deceived, that is, in the event of being manipulated. I think there are many flaws and rough edges that need to be smoothed out and fixed.esoxhunter71 said:Anyone that does not think of line poker is rigged is a moron
"iTech Labs conducts its RNG evaluations in accordance with the UK gambling Commission's Remote Gambling and Software Technical Standards.puzzlefish said:Ask ChatGPT to give you some sources of where it got its information and, more importantly, whether the audit methods have been validated and how.
HU4ROLLZmrfastflow said:I am amused by online poker defenders who have not even touched a professional poker play
I apologize in advance, I have not read the entire thread, however, just off the top of my head the only thing that comes to mind for an incentive for the site to RIG/Manipulate the RNG that I can think of is to advantage lesser players to keep them playing at the site versus just getting eaten alive MOST OF THE TIME by better players, becoming disgruntled and giving up. As for the RNG being exploitable either by inside or learned knowledge... that is an interesting thought... but I do not have a depth of knowledge regarding various RNGs and am having a hard time envisioning how just a "random" draw of remaining cards in the deck could be exploitable. Could you give me some ideas on what we are thinking about here?puzzlefish said:Ask ChatGPT to give you some sources of where it got its information and, more importantly, whether the audit methods have been validated and how.
I don't like to think of an RNG as rigged or not. I think of them as exploitable or not. Rigged implies that there is a particular benefit to the operator of the RNG. Exploitable means that someone with inside knowledge (or through learned knowledge) can target the RNG to get a particular result that is absolutely not random, in a predictable manner. I believe most (if not all) RNGs are exploitable.
Given this, the possibility of manipulation is not eliminated. Because an audit assesses the general panorama, but within this global panorama, manipulation can be balanced in order to make the accounts close, even if in specific cases, and also, convenient to the sites, they may favor players who promote, publicize and add value to the sites.S3mper said:"iTech Labs conducts its RNG evaluations in accordance with the UK Gambling Commission's Remote Gambling and Software Technical Standards.
Additionally, iTech Labs is an ISO/IEC 17025 accredited testing laboratory, which is a globally recognized standard for the competence of testing and calibration laboratories. This accreditation signifies that iTech Labs meets international standards for quality and reliability in testing procedures."
ISO/IEC 17025:
is a globally recognized international standard that specifies the general requirements for the competence of testing and calibration laboratories.
Here’s a breakdown of what it means and why it's a big deal:
🔍What is ISO/IEC 17025?
- Full Name: ISO/IEC 17025 – General requirements for the competence of testing and calibration laboratories
- Published by: International Organization for Standardization (ISO) and the International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC)
- Applies to: Any organization that performs testing, sampling, or calibration.
✅ Why It Matters for iTech Labs
If a lab like iTech Labs is ISO/IEC 17025 accredited, it means:
- They’ve been independently audited and meet strict technical and managerial standards.
- Their testing methods are validated and traceable to international standards.
- They must ensure ongoing proficiency, using calibrated equipment, and follow documented procedures.
- Their results are legally defensible and accepted internationally (very important for regulatory bodies like the UK Gambling Commission or Malta Gaming Authority).
📜 Example of How It Adds Trustworthiness
iTech Labs certified the RNG under ISO/IEC 17025 conditions, it means:
- The randomness was statistically proven using validated techniques.
- The lab itself is subject to oversight and has no stake in the game outcomes.
- The report can stand up to scrutiny in any regulatory or legal setting.
After looking I found they are currently accredited by NATA
Found here: https://nata.com.au/accredited-organisation/itech-global-pty-ltd-trading-as-itech-labs-15690-16823/?highlight=Itech labs
NATA:
NATA is Australia’s national accreditation body, similar to how UKAS operates in the United Kingdom. It’s a non-profit, government-authorized organization that provides independent accreditation to laboratories and inspection bodies.
Website: www.nata.com.au
✅ What Does NATA Do?
- Accredits labs to international standards like ISO/IEC 17025 (used for testing and calibration labs).
- Ensures that accredited labs are technically competent and produce reliable, traceable results.
- Conducts regular audits and assessments to maintain standards.
- Is internationally recognized through agreements like ILAC (International Laboratory Accreditation Cooperation), so a NATA-accredited lab is trusted globally.
On a side note AI is pretty awesome even in its infancy. What would've taken me hours took me about 5 minutes lol.
The audit has to be independent, I would say not even governmental, but rather like a form of poker syndicate, and even then, humans are disappointing...S3mper said:"iTech Labs conducts its RNG evaluations in accordance with the UK Gambling Commission's Remote Gambling and Software Technical Standards.
Additionally, iTech Labs is an ISO/IEC 17025 accredited testing laboratory, which is a globally recognized standard for the competence of testing and calibration laboratories. This accreditation signifies that iTech Labs meets international standards for quality and reliability in testing procedures."
ISO/IEC 17025:
is a globally recognized international standard that specifies the general requirements for the competence of testing and calibration laboratories.
Here’s a breakdown of what it means and why it's a big deal:
🔍What is ISO/IEC 17025?
- Full Name: ISO/IEC 17025 – General requirements for the competence of testing and calibration laboratories
- Published by: International Organization for Standardization (ISO) and the International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC)
- Applies to: Any organization that performs testing, sampling, or calibration.
✅ Why It Matters for iTech Labs
If a lab like iTech Labs is ISO/IEC 17025 accredited, it means:
- They’ve been independently audited and meet strict technical and managerial standards.
- Their testing methods are validated and traceable to international standards.
- They must ensure ongoing proficiency, using calibrated equipment, and follow documented procedures.
- Their results are legally defensible and accepted internationally (very important for regulatory bodies like the UK Gambling Commission or Malta Gaming Authority).
📜 Example of How It Adds Trustworthiness
iTech Labs certified the RNG under ISO/IEC 17025 conditions, it means:
- The randomness was statistically proven using validated techniques.
- The lab itself is subject to oversight and has no stake in the game outcomes.
- The report can stand up to scrutiny in any regulatory or legal setting.
After looking I found they are currently accredited by NATA
Found here: https://nata.com.au/accredited-organisation/itech-global-pty-ltd-trading-as-itech-labs-15690-16823/?highlight=Itech labs
NATA:
NATA is Australia’s national accreditation body, similar to how UKAS operates in the United Kingdom. It’s a non-profit, government-authorized organization that provides independent accreditation to laboratories and inspection bodies.
Website: www.nata.com.au
✅ What Does NATA Do?
- Accredits labs to international standards like ISO/IEC 17025 (used for testing and calibration labs).
- Ensures that accredited labs are technically competent and produce reliable, traceable results.
- Conducts regular audits and assessments to maintain standards.
- Is internationally recognized through agreements like ILAC (International Laboratory Accreditation Cooperation), so a NATA-accredited lab is trusted globally.
On a side note AI is pretty awesome even in its infancy. What would've taken me hours took me about 5 minutes lol.
Your point of view is interesting, very relevant.CheezeWiz said:I apologize in advance, I have not read the entire thread, however, just off the top of my head the only thing that comes to mind for an incentive for the site to RIG/Manipulate the RNG that I can think of is to advantage lesser players to keep them playing at the site versus just getting eaten alive MOST OF THE TIME by better players, becoming disgruntled and giving up. As for the RNG being exploitable either by inside or learned knowledge... that is an interesting thought... but I do not have a depth of knowledge regarding various RNGs and am having a hard time envisioning how just a "random" draw of remaining cards in the deck could be exploitable. Could you give me some ideas on what we are thinking about here?
Best of Luck at The Tables, All!
The audits cover backdoors and the ability to manipulate the deal.KingDOG said:KingDOG said:Given this, the possibility of manipulation is not eliminated. Because an audit assesses the general panorama, but within this global panorama, manipulation can be balanced in order to make the accounts close, even if in specific cases, and also, convenient to the sites, they may favor players who promote, publicize and add value to the sites.
They are government certified and meet international standards, but the company itself is independent.KingDOG said:The audit has to be independent, I would say not even governmental, but rather like a form of poker syndicate, and even then, humans are disappointing...
One way is for the whole hand to be predetermined, randomly, with a defined sequence of cards that will definitely be dealt. If a player knows what is coming, they can adjust their play.CheezeWiz said:but I do not have a depth of knowledge regarding various RNGs and am having a hard time envisioning how just a "random" draw of remaining cards in the deck could be exploitable. Could you give me some ideas on what we are thinking about here?
Is the company independent and who do they get paid to provide this service?S3mper said:The audits cover backdoors and the ability to manipulate the deal.
They are government certified and meet international standards, but the company itself is independent.
Ok so ChatGPT has shown you that this particular auditor is accredited and certified to conduct audits. Basically put, it meets standards set by the regulatory bodies for how they conduct testing. Now what is the evidence to show that their methods actually work to detect a rigged RNG? Have they ever detected rigged RNGs in the past? Do their methods cover every conceivable way that an RNG can be rigged? Do they share their methods with the companies whose RNGs they are testing? Is it possible that there is an RNG that is rigged in a way that this auditing company does not test? Is it possible that the RNG can be random in dealing cards but that there is a separate software that distributes cards to particular players depending on other parameters?S3mper said:"iTech Labs conducts its RNG evaluations in accordance with the UK Gambling Commission's Remote Gambling and Software Technical Standards.
Additionally, iTech Labs is an ISO/IEC 17025 accredited testing laboratory, which is a globally recognized standard for the competence of testing and calibration laboratories. This accreditation signifies that iTech Labs meets international standards for quality and reliability in testing procedures."
ISO/IEC 17025:
is a globally recognized international standard that specifies the general requirements for the competence of testing and calibration laboratories.
Here’s a breakdown of what it means and why it's a big deal:
🔍What is ISO/IEC 17025?
- Full Name: ISO/IEC 17025 – General requirements for the competence of testing and calibration laboratories
- Published by: International Organization for Standardization (ISO) and the International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC)
- Applies to: Any organization that performs testing, sampling, or calibration.
✅ Why It Matters for iTech Labs
If a lab like iTech Labs is ISO/IEC 17025 accredited, it means:
- They’ve been independently audited and meet strict technical and managerial standards.
- Their testing methods are validated and traceable to international standards.
- They must ensure ongoing proficiency, using calibrated equipment, and follow documented procedures.
- Their results are legally defensible and accepted internationally (very important for regulatory bodies like the UK Gambling Commission or Malta Gaming Authority).
📜 Example of How It Adds Trustworthiness
iTech Labs certified the RNG under ISO/IEC 17025 conditions, it means:
- The randomness was statistically proven using validated techniques.
- The lab itself is subject to oversight and has no stake in the game outcomes.
- The report can stand up to scrutiny in any regulatory or legal setting.
After looking I found they are currently accredited by NATA
Found here: https://nata.com.au/accredited-organisation/itech-global-pty-ltd-trading-as-itech-labs-15690-16823/?highlight=Itech labs
NATA:
NATA is Australia’s national accreditation body, similar to how UKAS operates in the United Kingdom. It’s a non-profit, government-authorized organization that provides independent accreditation to laboratories and inspection bodies.
Website: www.nata.com.au
✅ What Does NATA Do?
- Accredits labs to international standards like ISO/IEC 17025 (used for testing and calibration labs).
- Ensures that accredited labs are technically competent and produce reliable, traceable results.
- Conducts regular audits and assessments to maintain standards.
- Is internationally recognized through agreements like ILAC (International Laboratory Accreditation Cooperation), so a NATA-accredited lab is trusted globally.
On a side note AI is pretty awesome even in its infancy. What would've taken me hours took me about 5 minutes lol.
They get paid by their clients i.e. the sites they serveKingDOG said:Is the company independent and who do they get paid to provide this service?
It's not an excuse .but nothing I can say would convince you cause thinking about this rationally would hurt your little knob at the end of your spinal cord , commonly known as brain🙂esoxhunter71 said:And here we go again. Another person making another excuse for why a RNG made by corporations has no chance to be off.
You want it to be rigged. There's no audit in the world that can change your mind. Even if it were completely open sourced all hands revealed you would just argue the above.puzzlefish said:Ok so ChatGPT has shown you that this particular auditor is accredited and certified to conduct audits. Basically put, it meets standards set by the regulatory bodies for how they conduct testing. Now what is the evidence to show that their methods actually work to detect a rigged RNG? Have they ever detected rigged RNGs in the past? Do their methods cover every conceivable way that an RNG can be rigged? Do they share their methods with the companies whose RNGs they are testing? Is it possible that there is an RNG that is rigged in a way that this auditing company does not test? Is it possible that the RNG can be random in dealing cards but that there is a separate software that distributes cards to particular players depending on other parameters?
Does this company test for any time or result dependence of players' exposures to positive and negative variance?
It is possible that there are sites that are engaged in fraud. However, I think that in such top sites as 888 or PokerStars, this risk is minimal because the activities of such sites are controlled by authorised regulatory bodies and in case of any manipulations or even more so fraud, these sites can lose their very expensive licence.esoxhunter71 said:Anyone that does not think of line poker is rigged is a moron
I do have an audit in mind that would convince me, but it hasn't been done and most likely will never be done. Actually I am certain no site will ever do it.S3mper said:You want it to be rigged. There's no audit in the world that can change your mind. Even if it were completely open sourced all hands revealed you would just argue the above.
Is there any evidence whatsoever that it's rigged? No, therefore it must be rigged really good. Non falsifiable belief.
Who pays them then? Also, keep in mind Itech Labs is also audited as an ISO/IEC 17025 and must meet high standards that can be defended legally.puzzlefish said:I do have an audit in mind that would convince me, but it hasn't been done and most likely will never be done. Actually I am certain no site will ever do it.
I'll elaborate. For starters, the auditing company shouldn't be getting paid by the site being audited.
If the RNG itself is found completely random and this can be tested and it is also checked for backdoors and for the ability to be tampered with (which the audits cover) how are the above happening? Not to mention if anything is found in the above it's not necessarily (or even likely) to be RNG manipulation but collusion. That's on site security and if you want to argue that ACR's site security sucks. I don't think you'll find anyone who would disagree with that.puzzlefish said:Beyond that, the audit should include an examination of player variance profiles over time, within any given MTT and also within their accounts depending on changes in their account balances. Another important part would involve tracking variance profiles as they relate to stack size in MTTs (they should show no correlation).
It has to be funded by some agency that doesn't create a conflict of interest like a paying site does. Will that ever happen? Probably not.S3mper said:Who pays them then? Also, keep in mind Itech Labs is also audited as an ISO/IEC 17025 and must meet high standards that can be defended legally.
If the RNG itself is found completely random and this can be tested and it is also checked for backdoors and for the ability to be tampered with (which the audits cover) how are the above happening? Not to mention if anything is found in the above it's not necessarily (or even likely) to be RNG manipulation but collusion. That's on site security and if you want to argue that ACR's site security sucks. I don't think you'll find anyone who would disagree with that.
mrfastflow said:I am amused by online poker defenders who have not even touched a professional poker play
Speculation with no evidence so to hold to the belief that it's more likely rigged than not is dogmatism. Everything points to a fair deal. Absolutely everything.puzzlefish said:Regarding the other questions, who knows? Maybe it comes down to the RNG providing cards randomly but some other part of site software distributing them. Or maybe there is a built in part of the RNG that does that. It is just speculation on anybody's part.
Ok there is a difference between evidence to prove versus evidence to believe or evidence to suspect. There is more than enough evidence for me to suspect something unusual is happening. I don't really know what your background is, or why you feel the need to take the stance that you do. I don't agree with what you are saying and I feel comfortable leaving it at that.S3mper said:Speculation with no evidence so to hold to the belief that it's more likely rigged than not is dogmatism. Everything points to a fair deal. Absolutely everything.
You've probably had more unfair/rigged live deals than online deals.
What evidence?puzzlefish said:Ok there is a difference between evidence to prove versus evidence to believe or evidence to suspect. There is more than enough evidence for me to suspect something unusual is happening. I don't really know what your background is, or why you feel the need to take the stance that you do. I don't agree with what you are saying and I feel comfortable leaving it at that.
No, that's the worst part of it. You don't get paid.S3mper said:What evidence?
My background is shilling obviously. I get paid to defend the RNG's 😛