Luck or skill?

Flyer35

Flyer35

Per Ardua ad Astra
Loyaler
Joined
May 11, 2024
Total posts
3,989
Awards
5
CA
Poker Chips
1,187
Casino Coins
0
  • #51
At the lower (and probably higher) stakes everybody plays the same way. That means the result is determined by luck most of the time.
 
austral

austral

Rock Star
Platinum Level
Joined
Sep 24, 2025
Total posts
411
Awards
1
AR
Poker Chips
462
Casino Coins
0
  • #52
In a single hand, luck can be decisive, whereas over 500,000 hands, skill becomes far more important. Poker is not like chess, where virtually everything depends on skill. Nor is it like roulette, where virtually everything depends on chance. It lies somewhere in between: there is randomness in every deal, but skill determines who wins in the long run.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Noodeloo
Noodeloo

Noodeloo

Rock Star
Platinum Level
Joined
Dec 10, 2023
Total posts
222
Awards
1
GB
Poker Chips
204
Casino Coins
0
  • #53
The skill is to know which parts of the game require skill and which parts of the game require luck. Choosing what to do is the skill part. I choose to be lucky. Good luck on the felts
 
TheniT

TheniT

Visionary
Platinum Level
Joined
Mar 15, 2019
Total posts
500
Awards
2
BR
Poker Chips
477
Casino Coins
0
  • #54
As has been said many times before. Poker is a game of luck in the short term and skill in the long term. Luck affects individual hands and tournaments, but over a large sample, better decision-making, strategy, and discipline allow skilled players to consistently outperform weaker ones. Ultimately, skill determines long-term success and profitability.
 
Kasztor007

Kasztor007

Rock Star
Platinum Level
Joined
Feb 23, 2014
Total posts
189
Awards
1
Poker Chips
299
Casino Coins
0
  • #55
I think poker is mostly a game of skill, but luck is what makes it exciting.

In the short term, luck can decide who wins and loses. However, over a large sample of hands, skill becomes the dominant factor.

bankroll management, discipline, emotional control, and consistently making good decisions are what separate winning players from losing players.

If I had to put a percentage on it, I'd say poker is around 70-80% skill and 20-30% luck in the long run.
 
bronwen777

bronwen777

Rock Star
Platinum Level
Joined
Dec 26, 2015
Total posts
130
Awards
1
Poker Chips
251
Casino Coins
5
  • #56
Interresting question. I saw/read somewhere or seen something like winning say 36% of the time, makes you profitable. consistent over a long period. So the skill is in managing your game, bankroll, hands etc to stay profitable over the long term. if you were only lucky or unlucky 100% of the time. you would be unprofitable for certain. so skill must make up the balance. There are consistently well performing players out there, so tells you skill is absolutely important and the deciding factor
 
Mr.$t0k

Mr.$t0k

Visionary
Bronze Level
Joined
Aug 11, 2016
Total posts
570
Awards
3
UA
Poker Chips
377
Casino Coins
0
  • #57
I think it's more about skill than luck. Luck decides in 10 percent of cases, the rest is decided by your skills and abilities.
 
R

rufininha14

Visionary
Platinum Level
Joined
Jan 4, 2024
Total posts
507
BR
Poker Chips
630
Casino Coins
0
  • #58
In my opinion, it's about skill; relying solely on luck won't yield significant results. Study and learn poker techniques, and then you'll see good results.
 
S

ShroomTheRiver

Rising Star
Bronze Level
Joined
Jun 5, 2026
Total posts
2
GB
Poker Chips
28
Casino Coins
0
  • #59
AdelsonFagundes said:
Luck or skill?

Do you think that studying really makes a difference?

Is rake still fair today?

Is the winning player born with talent or discipline?
Luck is not under our control, so it shouldn't be spoken about. Skill very much is. Of course studying makes a difference. It increases your edge over your competition and that can be huge given the magnitude of what there is to learn. Rake is rake, easily beaten with proficiency and consistency. Be nice if we didn't have to pay it but the sites have gotta eat and it's remained somewhat consistent over the years.

"Hard work beats talent when talent fails to work hard" - to answer your final question. As in every walk of life there are people with innate talent. But a disciplined person who has none (talent) will mostly always outperform the lazy genius.
 
dompoker

dompoker

Legend
Platinum Level
Joined
Jul 22, 2019
Total posts
1,227
Awards
2
Poker Chips
796
Casino Coins
0
  • #60
In poker, it requires skill, patience, discipline, and self-control, but luck plays a big role in some plays, where a player loses, and in the end wins.
 
Pabloro10321

Pabloro10321

Visionary
Platinum Level
Joined
Jan 28, 2022
Total posts
679
Awards
2
AR
Poker Chips
373
Casino Coins
15
  • #61
I think that knowledge plays an important role, but luck also helps.
 
cwdignus

cwdignus

Carpe diem
Bronze Level
Joined
Jul 17, 2015
Total posts
3,030
Awards
4
BR
Poker Chips
691
Casino Coins
0
  • #62
Skill does help a little; someone with skill doesn't play every hand, they read the game quickly, but to win you need luck.
 
frnandoh

frnandoh

Legend
Bronze Level
Joined
Jul 27, 2016
Total posts
1,740
Awards
2
BR
Poker Chips
132
Casino Coins
0
  • #63
Sometimes we feel so smart that for us, it would be impossible to exist something that we can't learn. We can to hold accountable a lot of things by our own lost but only correcting our mistakes will bring us to the profit. If we don't trust on the game, why would we continue playing?;)
 
GLAVI65

GLAVI65

Rock Star
Bronze Level
Joined
Aug 24, 2020
Total posts
106
Awards
1
AR
Poker Chips
149
Casino Coins
0
  • #64
ferxo said:
Puedo decir y comentar que durante todo este tiempo que he estado jugando al póker, la suerte es un factor más que importante independientemente de la probabilidad, ya que a veces tener las mejores cartas no siempre es seguro que vayas a ganar según el análisis que se haya deducido de ellas.
We've all seen situations in which a player takes the money as a big favorite and ends up losing by an unlikely card on the turn or river. That doesn't mean that the decision was bad, but that the variation is part of the game.
 
martinoni

martinoni

Visionary
Platinum Level
Joined
Jan 20, 2022
Total posts
626
Awards
1
BR
Poker Chips
921
Casino Coins
10
  • #65
Its 20% luck and 80% skill for me
 
NSX_Amfe2nat

NSX_Amfe2nat

Rock Star
Platinum Level
Joined
May 22, 2022
Total posts
491
Awards
1
UA
Poker Chips
521
Casino Coins
5
  • #66
Both important. In one tournament - luck, in big distance - skill
 
K

kingaza1128

Rising Star
Bronze Level
Joined
Jun 6, 2026
Total posts
7
TH
Poker Chips
40
Casino Coins
0
  • #67
Skill 80%+ Luck20% = win
AK lose100%😭
 
thwenth1983

thwenth1983

Visionary
Platinum Level
Joined
May 26, 2019
Total posts
824
Awards
2
BR
Poker Chips
785
Casino Coins
0
  • #68
Good morning, everyone.

I have been playing poker since 2018 and, over the years, I have read a lot about variance, probabilities, hand equity, and strategy. Whenever someone asks whether poker is luck or skill, my answer is that poker is much more skill than luck.

Luck exists and it is important, because to win tournaments you need to win some all-ins and key situations. However, skill is fundamental for knowing which hands to play, which hands to raise, call, or fold, and for identifying your opponents' tendencies.

For example, in the later stages of tournaments, the players I consider strong usually play tighter ranges, so I know I need strong hands to face them. Against recreational players, the strategy can be different.

In the short term, luck has a significant influence on results. But in the long term, players who consistently make correct decisions tend to make money, while players who play poorly tend to lose money. That is why, in my opinion, poker is about 90% skill and 10% luck.
 
M

Macaroon

Rock Star
Silver Level
Joined
Feb 24, 2013
Total posts
316
Awards
1
GB
Poker Chips
562
Casino Coins
0
  • #69
The skill is in getting the best out of your big hands, or at least not losing a load of chips. The even bigger skill is making the best of any luck you might have, and not thowing a big win away needlessly. Everyone should read Dan Harrington's books, even if you decide you can't play like that.
 
Botuna

Botuna

Rock Star
Platinum Level
Joined
Feb 28, 2026
Total posts
144
ID
Poker Chips
178
Casino Coins
5
  • #70
ferxo said:
I can say and comment that throughout this time that I have been playing poker, luck is a more than important factor regardless of probability, since sometimes having the best cards it is not always certain that you will win based on the analysis that has been deduced from it.
yes my friend, for me who just got onto mtt on mid term, luck is a key factor to won it everything ;)
 
GLAVI65

GLAVI65

Rock Star
Bronze Level
Joined
Aug 24, 2020
Total posts
106
Awards
1
AR
Poker Chips
149
Casino Coins
0
  • #71
ferxo said:
Puedo decir y comentar que durante todo este tiempo que he estado jugando al póker, la suerte es un factor más que importante independientemente de la probabilidad, ya que a veces tener las mejores cartas no siempre es seguro que vayas a ganar según el análisis que se haya deducido de ellas.
I agree that luck plays an important role in poker, especially in the short term. However, I think the key is to differentiate between the outcome of a hand and the quality of the decision taken. Sometimes you can measure all the chips with the best hand or with the best mathematical probability and still lose. That doesn't mean the decision was wrong.
The variation is part of the game and is precisely what allows less experienced players to win specific hands or sessions. In the long term, odds and good decisions usually prevail, but in the short term, luck can change any outcome.
 
RomboPro777

RomboPro777

Enthusiast
Bronze Level
Joined
Jun 5, 2026
Total posts
38
UA
Poker Chips
46
Casino Coins
0
  • #72
this is not chess, so luck is always present here
 
Sschafell

Sschafell

Visionary
Platinum Level
Joined
Jun 9, 2016
Total posts
646
Awards
4
BR
Poker Chips
601
Casino Coins
0
  • #73
80% skill and 20% luck
 
B

bowserdon

Legend
Platinum Level
Joined
Jul 13, 2019
Total posts
1,143
Awards
2
CA
Poker Chips
964
Casino Coins
5
  • #74
I wud rather be lucky than good lol
 
V

valanddon

Legend
Platinum Level
Joined
Dec 26, 2016
Total posts
1,184
Awards
3
CA
Poker Chips
503
Casino Coins
0
  • #75
The only way skill is involved is bluffing your opponit, luck is making your hand.
 
Top