Horseshoe Online Casino New Jersey Review 2025

Horseshoe Casino NJ Bonuses and Promos:

Welcome Bonus

100% Bonus Back Up To $1,250

Welcome bonus

Welcome bonus	100% cashback bonus up to $1,250
Minimum deposit	$10
Bonus code	CASINOBONUSGOLD
Wagering requirements	1x

Horseshoe Casino NJ gives new players a 100% cashback casino bonus worth a maximum of $1,250. Deposit at least $10 and then choose between Horseshoe’s 2,200+ games.

If you have a net loss after the first two days, Horseshoe will refund 100% of your net losses up to a maximum of $1,250.

This is the largest cashback bonus offered in New Jersey. Horseshoe’s $1,250 is much more than Fanatics, which gives players $1,000, and other sites like Monopoly ($100).

We like cashback offers as you can play all your favorite games over your first two days and, if you have a net loss, you’ll get your funds back as a casino bonus. So, you can try out games with higher volatility or try some jackpot slots with the knowledge that, if you have a net loss, you’ll get some of that back!

Existing Player Bonuses

Horseshoe Casino NJ offers multiple existing player bonuses that change regularly. We visited Horseshoe Casino online multiple times throughout the week and found that the bonus selection was different every day.

Here’s an overview of the sorts of existing player bonuses we found when writing this review, but these are liable to change.

Deposit Bonus

Horseshoe Casino regularly offers a deposit bonus match. Simply deposit a certain amount to receive bonus cash. We think this is a great existing player bonus as it gives you a boost when you load up your bankroll.

Recently, Horseshoe Casino held a Summer Daily Deal promotion. Players can claim a 20% deposit match bonus worth up to $100.

We noticed that this offer has slightly higher wagering requirements than the welcome bonus. The wagering requirements vary by game: 2x on slots, 4x on all other games (except craps doesn’t contribute towards clearing the bonus). You must clear the wagering requirements within five days.

Exclusive Game Bonus

Horseshoe Casino frequently offers promos to encourage players to try a featured game. As with other existing player bonuses, it changes often but always highlights a new or exclusive game.

Earlier this year, Horseshoe offered a $5 casino bonus credit for Captain Bones Big Bounty when you deposited at least $20.

This offer came with 5x wagering requirements, but the wagering requirements included both the deposit amount and the bonus funds. This meant that, if you deposited $20 and received $5 in bonus cash, you had to wager $125($25 x 5) to clear the bonus.

In our experience, this is stricter than some wagering requirements, which usually only include bonus funds. We feel that some players may find it hard to clear this bonus, especially as you only have five days.

Leaderboards

Horseshoe Casino regularly holds leaderboards where players can compete to climb the ranks and win prizes by playing a particular game.

Earlier this year, Triple Coin Treasures: Shamrock Fortunes was the highlighted game, with $20,000 in prizes up for grabs. This included $1,000 in gift cards as well as smaller $25 and $100 casino bonus prizes.

We really like leaderboards as they add a competitive aspect to the casino gameplay, and you can win prizes even if you don’t come out on top at the end.

Referral Bonus

Horseshoe Casino has a referral program where you and your friend can receive 50 bonus spins for Sphinx Coin Boost. Simply share your referral link with your friends, and you’ll both receive the spins once your friend deposits and wagers at least $50.

Caesars Rewards

Horseshoe Casino players in New Jersey can join Caesars Rewards, one of our top-recommended loyalty programs in the US. Players earn Reward Credits just by playing their favorite games, which can be redeemed for various rewards online and in person.

Caesars Rewards Credits are flexible, as you can redeem them at both Horseshoe Casino and Caesars in New Jersey. Plus, you can also redeem your Rewards Credits at Caesars sportsbook.

If you want to use them for in-person rewards, you can redeem credits for hotel rooms, dining, entertainment, or casino credits at Caesars properties in New Jersey (including Caesars, Harrah’s, and Tropicana in Atlantic City) or across the country.

Horseshoe Casino NJ Deposits and Withdrawals

Horseshoe Casino in New Jersey makes depositing funds into your account easy. The minimum deposit for all payment methods is $10, which is also the minimum required to trigger the welcome bonus.

We like the fact that deposits are processed instantly so that you can play without delay. The casino doesn’t charge deposit fees but be aware that your credit card issuer may treat a casino deposit as a cash advance, and this can come with additional fees. We recommend you consider depositing using PayPal for fast deposits and no hidden fees.

Currently, there is not the option to deposit using Apple Pay or American Express credit cards in New Jersey. These are available at Horseshoe Casino in other states, so we hope players in New Jersey will soon have this option as well.

There is also the option to deposit in person at Caesars Sportsbook at Monmouth Park or in Atlantic City at Caesars, Harrah’s, or Tropicana.

Here’s an overview of the supported deposit methods at Horseshoe casino in NJ:

We found that Horseshoe Casino is one of the fastest payout casinos in New Jersey. Most withdrawals are processed instantly, and you should receive the funds within 48 hours.

In our experience, Play+ and PayPal are the fastest withdrawal methods. We received our funds within minutes via these methods. Debit card withdrawals take 1-2 days on average, while bank transfers can take up to five days.

The minimum withdrawal for all methods is $1, so Horseshoe is ideal for low-budget players. This minimum withdrawal is considerably lower than the $20 minimum at BetMGM.

Here’s an overview of the available withdrawal methods at Horseshoe:

Horseshoe Casino Apps

We were thoroughly impressed by Horseshoe’s mobile casino app, particularly on Apple devices. It has a score of 4.4/5.0 from over 4,200 verified Apple reviews, demonstrating how user-friendly it is on iPhones and iPads.

The Android score of 3.4/5.0 from 1,900+ reviews is still solid, illustrating that most users find the app intuitive and easy to navigate.

After testing the app ourselves, we were impressed by the sleek design which made navigating the app a breeze. It was simple to switch between the games, promotions, and customer service pages.

We also tested Horseshoe’s site on mobile browsers, including Safari and Chrome. The site loaded quickly, and the gameplay was smooth. We did find that the site looked cluttered on devices with smaller screens (such as an iPhone SE). So, we would highly recommend all players to download the dedicated mobile casino app for the best experience.

Horseshoe Casino Mobile Review

Available on

Horseshoe Casino NJ Games and Software

The lobby of 2,200+ games at Horseshoe Casino is one of the most extensive in New Jersey. This is much larger than BetMGM (1,500+) and Spin Palace (1,000+).

While many games here mirror those at Caesars online, there are plenty of Horseshoe exclusive slots and jackpot games you simply won’t find elsewhere.

We were particularly impressed with the variety of providers on show at Horseshoe. You can play iconic, all-time favorites from studios like AGS, IGT, and Novomatic, alongside the newest and most exciting slots from contemporary providers like Hacksaw Gaming and NetEnt.

Here’s an overview of the games on offer at Horseshoe Casino NJ:

Slots

Horseshoe is home to more than 2,000 fantastic online slots, including Horseshoe branded and exclusive slots you won’t find elsewhere. We recommend playing Horseshoe Rising Rewards and the excellent 3 Coin Cowboy, which offer enormous potential payouts and superb graphics.

You can also play legendary slots like IGT’s Cash Eruption, NetEnt’s Starburst, and the excellent Win Machine Deluxe. If you’re looking for potentially life changing wins, try one Horseshoe’s Jackpot Festival games like 88 Fortunes which have jackpots as high as $700,000!

Table Games

Horseshoe offers a reasonable selection of RNG table games, but you will find a broader offering at BetMGM. Still, you can play dozens of blackjack, baccarat, and roulette games, and there’s a solid line-up of poker-themed table games offering fast gameplay.

We really like Evolution’s first-person game series, like First-Person Lightning Baccarat, which blends traditional RNG table games with the feel of a live dealer title thanks to its immersive 3D environment.

Live Dealer

Although the live dealer selection at Horseshoe is smaller than that of Caesars, the quality of the games is top notch. Most of the titles are from Evolution and include exciting games like Monopoly Big Baller, Lightning Dice, and Crazy Time.

We love live dealer games as they combine the fast-paced action you’re used to at an online casino with the experience of interacting with a friendly live dealer. We also like that there are multiple Spanish-language titles which feature a Spanish-speaking dealer.

Poker

Although you can’t play cash poker games or tournaments at Horseshoe, you can enjoy RNG poker titles and a few live card games. Ultimate Texas Hold’em is a player favorite, while Caribbean Stud and Three-Card Poker are also worth playing at Horseshoe.

For something simpler, see the GameKing video poker titles, which award instant payouts if you can form a ranking poker hand of a pair of jacks or better.

Horseshoe Casino NJ Security and Licensing

As a regulated online casino in New Jersey, Horseshoe operates under a license issued by the New Jersey Division of Gaming Enforcement. As the site is regulated by the DGE, you can rest assured that it meets the highest standards of fairness.

We were pleased to find that Horseshoe utilizes site-wide SSL encryption to protect customer data. They also offer responsible gambling tools on the site, including deposit and loss limits, to ensure that your gameplay remains safe and fun.

Horseshoe Casino NJ Customer Support

Horseshoe Casino NJ provides customer support via live chat, email, and phone.

We contacted the customer support team via live chat and, after briefly chatting with an AI chatbot, were connected to a human support agent. In our experience, they were professional, friendly, and knowledgeable. We especially like the fact that customer support is available 24/7 via live chat.

You can also contact customer support via phone or email, but we found that the response times via email were much slower than the live chat, sometimes over 24 hours.

Horseshoe Casino NJ Reputation

Despite only launching in 2024, Horseshoe already has a positive reputation among players in the Garden State. Verified reviewers appreciate the low wagering requirements and excellent game variety.

The main critiques from players are related to payout delays, although those mostly seem to be due to verification delays. Players also criticized the slow response time of the customer service by email option with some players experiencing delays of more than 24 hours.

Horseshoe Casino NJ Review Conclusion

Overall, we were very impressed by Horseshoe Casino in New Jersey. The massive selection of games and generous spread of existing player promotions really make it stand out from the crowd.

As a Caesars Entertainment site, it’s hard not to directly compare Horseshoe to Caesars Palace online casino. The sites have a similar layout and the promotions, especially Caesars Rewards, are shared between them. So, it may be difficult to persuade dedicated Caesars players to swap to Horseshoe.

If you’re looking for a new online casino to try in New Jersey, we thoroughly recommend Horseshoe Casino.